Why do you think that HK said "Vertical Hinging" is manipulation?
Without having thought through your question. My simple intuition is that - U prolly has to do sumpin "bad" - Joel Chandler Harris said that -in dialect - Local Humor? ---(like I was exaggerating to in my previous comment)- to make it work. like a little extra cocking and bending in the wrists to get things on plane- or Just dont use accumulators #2 or #3? and a "little" pick N' Peck.
I could stir this pot a little-
I think there are easy and hard manipulations- likely BOTH vertical and horizontal hinging has manipulation and angled hinging does not need manipulation if it has coordination. I think vertical hinging and #3 do not fit without manipulation and Horizontal hunging and #2 accumulator do not fit without manipulation. Having said that I better explain- First , when a swing, we rotate so that the primary release of #2 is on plane and then we roll the clubface wertical so it passes "horizontal" to the ground BUT #2 is still uncocking and that is an vertical manipulation to allow the "sweet spot" to stay on the inclined plane. Now for vertical hinging #2 can be made coorinate and #3 must then be manipulated (reverse roll??) . I see it working with the horizontal hinge because everything is down, out or forward where with vertical hinging things are "kind of" down, in or back.
Realizing that this takes some visualization and a Lot of "hand flying" as the aerobatic pilot calls it. So- "hand fly" it yourself. That is what HK suggests!
The Bear
Last edited by HungryBear : 10-10-2010 at 12:46 PM.
Reason: stir the pot
Vertical Hinging requires a "Reverse" of the #3 Accumulator Roll. This Clockwise rotation is opposite of the Counterclockwise Roll that produce Angled and Horizontal Hinging. In other words, the Right Elbow would move faster than the Hands, which isn't going to happen, so "Action and Motion" must be produced by a "Reverse Swivel Roll" of the Hands. The Hands are Clamps, and therefore any disturbing motion is manipulation. Can we develop a "perfect Vertical Hinge" with a 3 dimensional Impact? Probably not, but we can come very close.
Vertical Hinging requires a "Reverse" of the #3 Accumulator Roll. ................... Can we develop a "perfect Vertical Hinge" with a 3 dimensional Impact? Probably not, but we can come very close.
Hybrid Mode
